Saturday, September 11, 2010

The Healing Power of Gelatin?


Gelatin has always seemed like one of the most nutritionally-neutral foods in the world to me. I've never really thought about it being healthy or unhealthy in itself, instead just making sure to check whether or not it's sugar-free. (It also never really hit me that gelatin without artificial flavorings could even be considered paleo.)

But low-carb guru Dana Carpender has been researching and exploring the health benefits of consuming gelatin -- both in its baking-aisle form and in its more natural, animal-bone-and-skin form -- and it sounds like she may be onto something here:
"Here's the main thing I gathered from it: You know how, over the past century or so, we've skewed our fatty acid intake by eating less animal fat and more vegetable oils, so that we're getting way too many omega-6 fatty acids and not enough omega-3s, too many unsaturates and not enough saturates? In exactly the same way, we have been skewing our balance of amino acids, the building blocks of protein. Gelatin-rich foods, from bone broths to head cheese to foods like pig's feet and ox tails, were a large part of a traditional diet. Our ancestors relished every part of the animal, and just as they ate organ meats that most modern Americans now spurn, they also ate all the gelatin-rich bony and cartilaginous bits of the animal. In this modern era of muscle meat and little but muscle meat -- think boneless skinless chicken breast -- much of this gelatin has vanished from the diet, but our bodies' need for it has not.
After naming joint health and energy boosts as positive side effects of gelatin, she goes on to list some other health benefits of the stuff:
Gelatin... with its glycine and proline, apparently does everything from reducing susceptibility to stress, to fighting tumors, to soothing the intestinal tract, to improving thyroid function. Dr. Peat also says it stimulates natural sleep,exciting stuff for this lifetime insomniac. It should be generally relaxing. And it should do very good things for skin. You've heard of collagen cream, right? I've known for years that the molecules were actually too big to penetrate the skin when applied topically, so these creams did nothing to strengthen our own collagen. On the other hand, taking it internally should be helpful. If I suddenly start getting mistaken for a 35 year old I'll let you know.
So weird, right? Bone-in meats have sort of always turned me off a little, and when I do tolerate them, I rarely get anywhere near the bone before I give up and push away my plate, but I can certainly start eating more Jell-O** or using plain gelatin as a thickening agent in my cooking. To read more about the many ways Dana is supplementing her diet with gelatin (including taking the plain powder by the teaspoonful with water), check out her whole post.

---------


**I should note here that Jell-O brand's sugar-free gelatin is sweetened with aspartame, which many health-minded folks try their best to avoid these days due to its reputation as a neurotoxin. Katie and I have explained in the comments discussion following this post how we still enjoy it in moderation, but I would hate for this post to encourage anyone to start loading up on large quantities of aspartame-sweetened Jell-O. I've read that there are a few ways to make your own flavored gelatin with your sweetener of choice, such as mixing unflavored gelatin with Kool-Aid packets and sweetener or DaVinci's sugar-free syrups, but I can't vouch for exact amounts of each since I've never tried it. Perhaps I'll give it a go and share what I find out.

Comments (11)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I just finished reading her article on gelatin - impressive! I think I'll do a bit more reading on the subject, very interesting. Just by reading what she's experienced makes me want do take some before bed tonight! I'm anxious to read about her results.

Thanks for the info!
1 reply · active 759 weeks ago
I had some plain gelatin in my cabinet, and I tried taking a spoonful last night, and it was AWFUL. Before I could chase it with water, it completely sealed to the roof of my mouth, and I spent the next hour gulping water and obsessively trying to scrape it away with my tongue so I could swallow it. I'm not sure how she's tolerating taking it dry, but I think I'm going to stick to it in its prepared forms.
Wow, guess I can feel good about all of those headcheeses I've eaten in the past year in an effort to be more "adventurous", huh? I do have an aversion to fat and bones, but I know it's only because I was raised to cut the fat off of my food. It still amazes me when I get a melt-in-your-mouth fatty hunk of meat at a nice restaurant. Skinless and boneless is supposed to be gross!

It looks like one of the commenters had the same experience you did, and Dana only replies that she's "an accomplished swallower". Haha. Would it work to mix the gelatin into a glass of water? It can't set immediately, right?
3 replies · active 759 weeks ago
Yeah. none of those comments were there yet when I saw the post and tried this, so I ended up taking a bullet on that one. I certainly won't be trying that again. I was thinking that mixing it into water would help it go down, too.

You KNOW, a few days ago when you posted about pudding mix and yogurt, I actually attempted your recipe with a packet of SF lemon Jell-O instead of pudding, and even though it came out tasting good, the texture came out all powdery since I never let the gelatin dissolve in hot water like you're supposed to. I was close to throwing it out, but now that I know how good for me the gelatin in it is, I've been eating it all weekend. If I prepared it like you're actually supposed to (maybe one cup boiling water and then one cup cold yogurt), I'll bet that would be a GREAT way to get more gelatin.
WOW. That is genius. Regular Jell-o bores me so much because it doesn't have any of that creamy texture I crave, but this would be a great way for me to get rid of all the gelatin powder I have stockpiled AND get my gelatin supplement for the day. I just had a new container of Fage delivered yesterday, so I'm going to do this tonight. Thanks, friend!

I'm kind of interested in that powdery texture, though. I don't know if I've ever told you this, but I love to not mix my pudding up very well so there are little pockets of powder left.
I can't take full credit for that recipe, since the new Atkins book recommended doing the same thing, only with heavy cream instead of yogurt for the cold liquid. All I did was combine that idea with your yogurt recipe.

I found the powdery (more like grainy?) texture rather unpleasant, but not inedible. If you're curious, try sprinkling just a tiny bit of gelatin powder in a spoonful of cold yogurt and try it. If you're not into it, I would try it the other way.
I poured a whole package of the Knox into a cup of hot tea! Then stirred until all dissolved and enjoyed it while watching a tv show w/my hubby. I was hoping it would help me sleep as I have ALWAYS had trouble staying asleep for more than 2-3 hrs max.

Didn't work :(
1 reply · active 758 weeks ago
I've had a spoonful in water or a serving of Jell-O nearly every day since I read Dana's post, and I'm still waiting to experience a rush of benefits. I still feel like I'm doing something good for my health, because the rationale behind its good-for-you-ness makes sense to me, but I think the "miracle" results might be a little hit or miss.
swallow's nest in an edible gel form is supposed be good for the skin too. it gives that clear and pasty skin that we all love.

it's mad expensive. my brother and i bought some for my mom for her birthday. it was like 400 bucks for like a 6-8 oz jar. Luckily we finally found the one of popular brand online (hongkong-bird-nest.50webs.com/index_e.htm and http://www.euyansang.com/)

dad said it's really popular in indonesia. that a guy has to climb a high mountain to get the nest. that's why it's so expensive.

i mean why doesn't the dude just look for the fabled korean swallow king, capture it and let it lay eggs full of gold! then, he wouldn't have to work so hard and climb them high mountains.
what ingredients in it
How much gelatin?

Post a new comment

Comments by