Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Vitamins and Protein Powder

Once upon a time, Tracey’s mom consulted her local GNC employees about a low-carb protein powder and came up with SEI Pharmaceuticals’ Max Protein. It has a bit of a clumping problem that makes it very annoying to clean out of shaker bottles, but it’s delicious and very low-carb at 3g carbs and 1g sugar for a 30g scoop.

However, it’s $50 for 2 lbs., which didn’t bother me before when protein shakes weren’t a habit of mine, but now that I’m sometimes having multiple shakes in one day, it seems pretty excessive.

A muscle-building friend of mine talked me into buying the protein powder he uses, which is Dymatize Elite Gourmet. It has 5g carbs and 0g sugar for a 32g scoop because it’s made with sucralose, no clumping, and a different but still great taste. And it’s only $29 for 5 pounds, so it’s a major savings.

The problem is that the Dymatize contains almost no vitamins, whereas the SEI is loaded with them. I read a blog where a woman was breaking a multivitamin into her protein shakes to make them more nutritious, and I wondered if anyone had any thoughts on that.

Does it matter if my vitamins are part of the original powder or something I add myself? Does it matter if I have the vitamins in the shake or alongside it?

I kind of assume that taking a multivitamin right before or after I drink my shake is the same as breaking it up into the shake itself, but I’m no doctor of vitamin-absorption.

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I don't want to weigh in too much yet, since I'm interested in what others think and since we already sorta talked about this on the phone, but the more I think about it, the less sure I am that a normal blender can really tackle getting a vitamin ground up properly. I mean, I know it can do a good job with ice and all, but if I hit a chunk of vitamin that I had to chew up, I think it would make me gag.
I'm really loving my Perfect Zero Carb Isopure. I've never even considered a chocolate flavored whey but with this brand, I'll be ordering it in the near future. Finding a whey you like is sooo important! I was using a cheap brand and finally, because of the reviews, ordered the IsoPure - soooo glad. I paid 37 + 4.98 shipping (Netrition). I also ordered other things so the shipping isn't bad at all.

As for the vitamin-hm...don't know. I thought they had to be swallowed whole?
In my opinion (which is worth nothing, of course) the only vitamin you probably need to "supplement" is D3- because technically it's more of a hormone than a vitamin anyway. I would not stress too much about vitamins (except D) because it all seems like a lot of hype to me. And there's not a lot of good research out there supporting supplementing with vitamins. However, you should always do what is working for your body, so if vitamins are good for you, keeping on rocking them. As long as you eat some good vegetables and fruit in season it seems to me that your body will figure the rest out.
I agree with Ryan. Since your body has been use to a vitamin supplement I don't see what the harm is by taking them on the side and just be sure that you are eating plenty of veggies and fruit as well!
So what all do you mix in your protein shakes? Is it just powder and milk, or do you add other stuff?
1 reply · active 759 weeks ago
I've been thinking that Katie and I should post about this sometime soon. I think we've made them so many different ways now, it's ridiculous.

Regular milk is a little too high-carb for us (although unsweetened almond or soy milk would work well), but a mixture of water and heavy cream makes a good base for a shake. That's enough if you like the taste of your powder. (A little powder mixed into a couple of ounces of pure heavy cream makes the most delicious dessert, and if you actually whip it, it's chocolate mousse.)

After that. the options are pretty much endless depending on how many carbs you want to add.. Spoonfuls of natural peanut butter, dollups of sugar-free jam, shots of sugar-free syrups, instant coffee granules (or actual prepared coffee), tiny amounts of those flavoring extracts you find in the baking aisle, etc. My favorite way is to get out the blender and blend in frozen berries, ice, and a little cocoa powder and Splenda.

Post a new comment

Comments by